ALL THINGS FOOD AND DIET
I Want To:
Record a Journal Entry
My Weight History
My Diet Calendar
My Forum Posts
My Cook Book
Go To My FatSecret
Measuring Body Fat
Topic submitted for
Joined: Apr 10
Posted: 16 Dec 2010, 00:48
There a lots of tools online to help calculate body fat percentage. Here are a few:
My own limited experience with the scales is that they are pretty inaccurate. I got similar readings from body measurement tools online and a hand-held monitor, and on the same day got a body fat reading from a scale that was 10 percentage points off.
Short of a dunk test, my understanding is that calipers are supposed to be most accurate. I think proper training is essential for this. I bought some and failed to get an accurate reading so many times that I gave up. The Myotape that came free with my calipers is awesome, though, and totally worth $6 if you plan to do a lot of measuring.
Joined: Sep 10
Posted: 16 Dec 2010, 07:58
Based on the research I've done, electrical impedance is the best way to go.
I looked at calipers and the conclusion is if you don't know how to use them correctly, they are not accurate because you have to measure the same spots time after time. Based on the reading I did, this is especially true if you are trying to use them on yourself.
Omron makes good products. I opted to get a the HBF-514 scale and body fat monitor. I was within 3% of what a personal trainer calculated for me using calipers so I feel comfortable that it is relatively accurate.
Where the electrical impedance devices don't do well is if you are athletic. If you're athletic, then you need to get a device that allows you to select that feature - the Omron handheld device has this feature.
Joined: Jan 09
Posted: 16 Dec 2010, 08:38
I'd say calipers. But you have to have a nurse, doctor, or other trained person do it. I have a bodyfat scale that is completely inaccurate for the reason mentioned above. It doesn't know the difference between muscle and fat. I read a lot about them and it seems they perform a calculation that involves your weight, height, and some measure of impedence. The scales only measure your lower body. If you are at all muscular, you won't get an accurate reading. I've lost 20 lb since I got the scale, yet the bf % reading has gone up. Calipers (done by doctor) put me around 23%. The scale says 38.
None of the online calculators are going to be accurate for everyone. How could they be? We are all different
. I think the only way to know for sure is to get dunked. I've thought about doing that, but in the end decided to just go with how I feel, look, and how the clothes fit. That's what really matters to me anyway.
My blog, This is not a Diet:
Follow me on Facebook for tips, recipes, advice, exercise ideas and more:
Advanced forum search
Diets and Dieting
Special Dieting Situations
Promote your Diet
Food and Recipes
Tricks of the Trade
Look at Me
Fitness & Exercise
My Fitness Program
Different Types of Exercise
Life is Fun
My Secrets for a Great Life
The FatSecret Site
View All Tannis' Diet Topics
ECO Atkins for a skinny vegetarian with a belly
This would be a good question for the nutritionist over on the atkins.com boards. Colette Heimowitz is her name. Post your question with her name in the title and she will respond.
on 18 May 13 09:58 AM
I hate days off
Weekends are hard for me too, but last weekend I made sure to come on here and record everything and that helped. I don't know if you record on weekends or not, but if you don't it may help. I ...
on 15 May 13 03:54 PM
I have 4 kids, I had my twins by C-Section and then two natural VBACs. I have noticed an improvement since I started working out my abs. I doubt it's doing anything for the loose skin itself, but ...
on 14 May 13 10:36 AM
And just for the record - I don't recommend it!! ;-)
on 13 May 13 05:41 AM
How below should one be from their RDI?
Just found the above mentioned Harris-Benedict Equation today in a Shape.com article. Searched for a topic and this thread was here. Going to adjust my caloric intake accordingly. Glad to see others ...
on 12 May 13 06:55 PM
view more posts
You have to eat to lose weight! Constant eating is kind of like maintaining a fire - you have to keep feeding the fire to keep it going strong. Wants the fire is constantly fed, it produces the heat ...
16 Nov 10 for diet
view more tips
© 2013 FatSecret. All rights reserved.